By the Slice $4.50 +tax

Whole Pies always ready for pickup or call for special orders

Call for whole pie prices

Our Pies are baked fresh daily, though not all pies are available daily and all fruit is subject to season. 

Our menu serves as a guide to placing your order.


Sugar Free pies available by order.


Crumb topping by request


Call 2 days in advance for Pie Orders.  

Fruit & Nut

Pies Are Seasonal & Daily Selection Varies

  • Apple (Crumb Topping Option)

  • Apricot

  • Blackberry

  • Blueberry (Crumb Topping Option)

  • Cherry (Crumb Topping Option)

  • Mix Berry (Crumb Topping Option)

  • Mincemeat

  • Nectarine

  • Peach (Crumb Topping Option)

  • Pear  *Seasonal

  • Pecan

  • Plum

  • Raisin

  • Raspberry

  • Rhubarb

  • Strawberry


Cream  Pies

  • Pumpkin

  • Chocolate Truffle

  • Coconut

  • Sour Cream Lemon

  • Banana *Whole Pie Only by Order




Our Most Popular Pie
Lemon Sour Cream

Phone (928) 778-1223

Local Pickup Only


802 Valley Street

Prescott, Arizona 86305


Tuesdays thru Saturdays


8:00am - 2:00pm


8:00am - 3:00pm

Closed Sundays & Mondays 

  • Facebook Grunge
  • Grey TripAdvisor Icon

© 2019 Rustic Pie Compnay 

Photography & Website 

Created By

 Way Out West Photography


Graphics & Signs by www.davidpalmersigns.com